Reviews, Meta-Reviews & Author Feedback Visibility Cheat Sheet
| REVIEWS VISIBLE TO AUTHOR DURING AUTHOR FEEDBACK | META-REVIEWS VISIBLE TO AUTHOR DURING AUTHOR FEEDBACK |
|---|---|
| 1. Author Feedback needs to be set to 'Enabled' with an end-date set in the future | 1. Author Feedback needs to be set to 'Enabled' with an end-date set in the future |
| 2. The Review questions need to be checked – 'Visible to authors during author feedback' | 2. The Meta-Review questions need to be checked – 'Visible to authors during author feedback' |
| 3. 'Requested For Author Feedback?' needs to be enabled in the Chair Console | 3. 'Requested For Author Feedback?' needs to be enabled in the Chair Console |
| REVIEWER COMMENTS VISIBLE TO AUTHOR DURING AUTHOR FEEDBACK | META-REVIEWER COMMENTS VISIBLE TO AUTHOR DURING AUTHOR FEEDBACK |
|---|---|
| 1. Author Feedback needs to be set to 'Completed' with an end-date set in the past | 1. Author Feedback needs to be set to 'Completed' with an end-date set in the past |
| 2. The Review questions need to be checked – 'Visible to authors during author feedback' | 2. The Meta-Review questions need to be checked – 'Visible to authors during author feedback' |
| 3. 'Requested For Author Feedback?' needs to be enabled in the Chair Console | 3. 'Requested For Author Feedback?' needs to be enabled in the Chair Console |
| 4. 'AUTHOR FEEDBACK COMMENT SECTION' needs to be enabled in Author Feedback Settings | 4. 'AUTHOR FEEDBACK COMMENT SECTION' needs to be enabled in Author Feedback Settings |
| AUTHOR FEEDBACK VISIBLE TO REVIEWERS | AUTHOR FEEDBACK VISIBLE TO META-REVIEWERS |
|---|---|
| 1. 'Requested For Author Feedback?' needs to be enabled in the Chair Console | 1. 'Requested For Author Feedback?' needs to be enabled in the Chair Console |
| 2. The Author Feedback questions need to be checked – 'Visible to Reviewers' | 2. The Author Feedback questions need to be checked – 'Visible to Meta-Reviewers' |
| 3. Author Feedback needs to be set to 'Completed' with an end-date that has passed (This is only for Reviewer. Meta-Reviewer does not need this step) | 3. Author Feedback needs to be submitted by the author |
| 4. Author Feedback needs to be submitted by the author |