HOW-TO: Review Rating

OVERVIEW

The Meta-Reviewer 'Review Rating' needs to be enabled by the Chair. After the Reviews are in, the Meta-Reviewers can rate the Reviews.

META-REVIEWER CONSOLE

• From the 'Meta-Reviewer Console,' click ‘View Reviews’ in the ‘Completed’ column of the ‘Review’ section.

The ‘View Reviews’ page opens.

VIEW REVIEWS PAGE

• Click the ‘Rate Review’ dropdown to choose your rating. Do this for all the completed Reviews for the paper. Return to the Meta-Reviewer Console.

The ratings are given a value which can be seen by the chair with the higher the number the better the rating - the highest being 3.

Failed to Meet Expectations - 1
Met Expectations - 2
Exceeded Expectations - 3

META-REVIEWER CONSOLE: REVIEW RATING COLUMN

The Reviewer Rating has been posted for the paper.
In this example, this row has:

Review Rating Completed = 2
% Completed = 100

Notice there are 3 reviewers assigned but only 2 reviewers have given their reviews for a completion percentage of 66%.

Of the 2 completed reviews, the Meta-Reviewer gave 2 ratings, this is why the Review Rating percentage complete is at 100%.

When the 3rd reviewer finally reviews the paper, the Review Rating percentage complete will go from 100% to 66%, and the Review percentage complete will then be 100%.